Bank of Ghana revokes licenses of five commercial banks, forms Consolidated Bank
The crisis in Ghana’s banking sector started unfolding in August 2017 with the collapse of UT and Capital Banks was long in coming. Today’s announcement by the Bank of Ghana that it has revoked the licenses five commercial banks and licensed a new bank is no surprise to watchers of the country’s banking sector.
This afternoon, August 1, 2018, the Governor of the central bank, Dr. Ernest Addison announced the revocation of the licenses of the following five commercial banks – uniBank Ghana Limited, The Royal Bank Limited, Beige Bank Limited, Sovereign Bank Limited, and Construction Bank Limited and appointed Mr. Nii Amanor Dodoo of KPMG as the Receiver for the five banks.
“All deposits of the five banks are safe and have been transferred to the Consolidated Bank. Customers can carry out their business as usual at their respective banks which will now become branches of the Consolidated Bank. All staff of these banks will become staff of the Consolidated Bank. Boards of Directors and shareholders of these banks no longer have any roles,” Dr. Addison told journalists in Accra.
The Governor added that Ghana needs a strong and stable banking sector to drive the process of economic transformation.
“A weak banking sector means that access to credit will be limited while lending rates will continue to be high,” he said.
The Governor gave the following background to the circumstances leading to the collapse of the five banks.
Background
The Bank of Ghana has taken the above measures as part of its efforts to address legacy problems in the banking sector and to restore the stability and resilience of the financial system. While some of the weaknesses in the sector were attributable to macroeconomic factors, a trend of poor corporate governance, poor risk management practices, related party transactions that were not above board, regulatory noncompliance, and poor supervision (questionable licensing processes and weak enforcement) had emerged over the years, leading to a significant build-up of vulnerabilities in the sector.
uniBank
It would be recalled that on 20th March 2018, the Bank of Ghana appointed KPMG as Official Administrator (OA) for uniBank to help ascertain the true financial condition of the bank, protect depositors’ funds held by the bank, and explore how the bank could be returned to viability within a period of no later than six months.
In line with the requirements of Act 930, KPMG submitted an Inventory of Assets and Liabilities of uniBank (Ghana) Limited on April 20, 2018 (30-day report), and a report on the Financial Conditions and Future Prospects of uniBank (Ghana) Limited on June 20, 2018 (90-day report).
KPMG’s reports confirmed, based on a detailed review and validation of the financial condition of uniBank that the bank was balance sheet insolvent at the time of their appointment as official administrator and remains so.
As official administrator, KPMG made efforts to ascertain the assets and liabilities of the bank and evaluated options for turning around the bank’s fortunes. KPMG, however, found that the bank’s operations are not sustainable.
Among other things, the bank’s interest income and other sources of income are insufficient to cover the associated cost of funds of underlying borrowings and liabilities, as well as overheads of about GH¢0.31 billion per annum. A significant portion of the bank’s loan book which forms the largest component of the bank’s assets, is non-performing.
The earning capacity of the bank continues to deteriorate. In addition, the bank’s governance and internal control environments have been assessed as weak, with significant deficiencies in credit underwriting and loan approval process, compliance and reporting.
Key findings from KPMG’s reports indicated serious corporate governance, risk management, compliance and management flaws, as well as unlawful transactions involving shareholders, related parties, and connected parties.
In particular: uniBank had given out amounts totaling GH¢1.6 billion to shareholders and related parties in the form of loans and advances without due process and in breach of relevant provisions of Act 930. In addition, these shareholders and related parties had also been given amounts totaling GH¢3.7 billion which were neither granted through the normal credit delivery process nor reported as part of the bank’s loan portfolio.
They were also not secured with collateral, and attracted no interest income for uniBank. Altogether, shareholders and related parties of uniBank had taken out an amount of GH¢5.3 billion, constituting 75 per cent of total assets of the bank; Out of total customer deposits of GH¢4.3 billion, GH¢2.3 billion was not disclosed to the Bank of Ghana.
Loans and advances to customers were also overstated by GH¢1.3 billion in prudential returns to the Bank of Ghana;
Over 89 per cent of uniBank’s loans and advances book of GH¢3.74 billion as of May 31, 2018 was classified as non-performing, in addition to amounts totaling GH¢3.7 billion given out to shareholders and related parties which were not reported as part of the bank’s loan portfolio; After making allowances for impairments to recognise the deterioration in the quality of uniBank’s assets and other requirements under Bank of Ghana’s capital adequacy framework, uniBank was balance sheet insolvent with negative shareholders’ funds of GH¢6.78 billion as at May 31, 2018 (representing assets of GH¢2.38 billion less liabilities of GH¢9.15 billion);
The bank therefore has a capital deficit of GH¢7.4 billion, compared to the regulatory minimum of GH¢400 million;
After making adjustments to uniBank’s balance sheet to offset outstanding debts totaling GH¢428,817,961 owed it by Government contractors (backed by Interim Payment Certificates issued by the Government), the bank’s liabilities (including an amount of GH¢3.04 billion owed to the Bank of Ghana) remain significantly more than its assets, and is therefore insolvent.
To summarise, as of May 31, 2018, uniBank was insolvent, with a capital deficit of GH¢7.4 billion (compared to the regulatory minimum of GH¢400 million), and a capital adequacy ratio (CAR) of negative 74.65 per cent (compared to the regulatory minimum of 10 per cent).
uniBank is also cash-flow insolvent, given that a significant portion of the its assets are locked up in interest-free loans and other advances to its shareholders and related parties. As a result of the financial condition of the bank, it has continued to survive largely on liquidity support to meet maturing liabilities including operating expenses.
As of June 2018, total liquidity support that has been provided to uniBank was GH¢3.1 billion, including approximately GH¢927.2 million provided since the appointment of KPMG in March 2018.
KPMG estimates that uniBank will need additional liquidity support estimated at GH¢3.0 billion through the end of 2018 to help meet overdue and maturing obligations and operating expenses.
Further reliance on liquidity support at this stage is unsustainable, and the bank’s continued inability to honour outstanding obligations to depositors including financial institutions, public sector institutions, and others, continues to fuel liquidity pressures in the financial system.
uniBank’s shareholders and related parties have admitted to acquiring several real estate properties in their own names using the funds they took from the bank under questionable circumstances.
Promises by these shareholders and related parties to refund monies by mid-July 2018 and legally transfer title to assets acquired back to uniBank have failed to materialize.
Based on the Bank of Ghana’s review of KPMG’s assessment of the financial condition of uniBank, the Bank of Ghana has concluded that uniBank is insolvent and has no reasonable prospect of rehabilitation, or a reasonably credible path to viability.
In arriving at this conclusion, the Bank of Ghana has carefully considered the options provided under Act 930 to rehabilitate a bank under official administration. The Bank of Ghana finds that, in the interest of promoting financial stability, protecting the interests of depositors and lenders, minimising the costs to the tax payer, and restoring integrity in the financial sector, the only reasonable option is to fully resolve the bank by revoking its banking licence and winding down its affairs through a receiver appointed by the Bank of Ghana.
The Royal Bank
Royal Bank was licensed as a universal bank in October 2012. It has over the last few years experienced solvency and acute liquidity challenges.
An on-site examination conducted by the Bank of Ghana in March 31, 2018 revealed a number of irregularities. The Bank of Ghana appointed an advisor for Royal Bank in May 2018 to advise management of the bank, with the primary mandate to stabilize and improve the affairs of the bank.
Based on the Bank of Ghana’s assessment, Royal is insolvent and faced with acute liquidity challenges.
Specifically: The bank suffered severe capital impairment due to under-provisioning for loans, over estimation of investments with other financial institutions, and overstatement of capital on account of fixed assets which were rejected by the Bank of Ghana for capital purposes.
This resulted in an adjusted capital of negative GH¢484 million, yielding a CAR of negative 80.53 per cent, a capital deficiency of GH¢567.78 million and a net-worth of negative GH¢498.63 million as at May 31, 2018;
The bank has persistently faced serious liquidity challenges since September 2017, resulting in the continuous breach of the cash reserve ratio required by section 36 of Act 930. It has survived on liquidity support totaling GH¢295 million;
Its non-performing loans constitute 78.79 per cent of total loans granted, owing to poor credit risk and liquidity risk management controls;
A number of the bank’s transactions totaling GH¢161.92 million were entered with shareholders and related parties structured to circumvent single obligor limits under Act 930, conceal related party exposure limits under Act 930, and to overstate the capital position of the bank for the purpose of complying with the capital adequacy requirement.
The Beige Bank Limited
The Beige Bank commenced banking operations in December 2017 after operating as a savings and loans company.
A special examination conducted by the Bank of Ghana into the affairs of the bank six months after the commencement of its operations, revealed that: Funds purportedly used by the bank’s parent company to recapitalize were sourced from the bank through an affiliate company and in violation with regulatory requirements for bank capital.
In particular, an amount of GH¢163.47 million belonging to the bank was placed with one of its affiliate companies (an asset management company) and subsequently transferred to its parent company which in turn purported to reinvest it in the bank as part of the bank’s capital. The placement by the bank with its affiliate company amounted to 86.86 per cent of its net own funds as at end June 2018, thereby breaching the regulatory limit of 10 per cent.
Furthermore, the purported use of the same funds by the parent company of the bank to reinvest in the bank was in contravention of the Bank of Ghana’s requirements for bank capital. Also, the bank has not been able to recover these funds for its operations.
The bank persistently breached the cash reserve requirement (CRR) of 10 per cent (CRR at July 23, 2018 was 1.97 per cent) since the beginning of January 2018;
The quality of the bank’s loan portfolio had seriously deteriorated resulting in a NonPerforming Loans Ratio (NPL) of 72.80 per cent;
The bank’s Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) was assessed to be negative 17.18 per cent as against the regulatory minimum of 10 per cent, thus, recording a capital deficit of GH¢159,162,557.64, rendering the bank insolvent.
Sovereign Bank Limited
(“Sovereign”) Sovereign Bank Limited was licensed as a universal bank in January 2016 and began operations in April 2016.
As part of Bank of Ghana’s investigations into the failure of Capital Bank Limited (currently in receivership), it emerged that Sovereign Bank’s initial capital contributed by its shareholders was funded from transfers from Capital Bank which had been presented to the Bank of Ghana as investments on behalf of the bank.
Subsequent to its licensing, a substantial amount of the bank’s capital was placed with another financial institution as an investment for the bank. The bank has however not been able to retrieve this amount from the investment firm with which it was placed, and it has emerged that the investments were liquidated by the shareholders and parties related to them.
Following enquiries by the Bank of Ghana, the promoters of the bank admitted that they did not pay for the shares they acquired in the bank. The promoters of the bank have since surrendered their shares to the bank, while the directors representing those original shareholders have since resigned.
In April 2018, the Bank of Ghana appointed an Advisor to advise the management of the bank with a view to improving the affairs of the bank. Following further deterioration in the capital of the bank due to its inability to recover the investments placed with financial institutions, as well as impairments to its loan book, its capital adequacy ratio is currently negative.
The Bank of Ghana has concluded that Sovereign Bank is insolvent, and that there is no reasonable prospect of a return to viability. The bank is unable to meet daily obligations as they fall due. Liquidity support granted so far to the bank amounts to GH¢12 million as of May 2018.
The bank has not been able to publish its audited accounts for end December, 2017 breaching section 90 (2) of Act 930. The bank’s current situation has resulted in persistent breaches of key regulatory requirements and prudential limits.
The Construction Bank Limited
(“Construction Bank”) Construction Bank was licensed in May 2017 and commenced operations in December 2017. In the course of the official administration of uniBank, the Bank of Ghana discovered certain transactions involving Construction Bank. Further investigations revealed that:
The initial minimum paid up capital of the bank provided by its promoter/shareholder, was funded by loans obtained from NIB Bank Limited (GH¢34 10 million) and uniBank (Ghana) Limited (GH¢61.00 million), contrary to section 9 (d) of Act 930;
An amount of GH¢80 million out of the amounts reported as the bank’s paid up capital and purportedly placed with NIB and uniBank, remains inaccessible to the bank;
The bank’s inability to inject additional capital to restore its capital adequacy to the minimum capital of GH¢120 million required at the date of licensing threatens the safety of depositors’ funds and the stability of the banking system.
Owing to the bank’s inability to access investments purportedly made in its name with other financial institutions, the Bank of Ghana has concluded that a total of GH¢80 million of the bank’s GH¢120 million initial paid up capital is unavailable to the bank for its operations, leaving an amount of GH¢40 million (one-third of the minimum capital of GH¢120 million).
The Bank of Ghana has since requested the bank’s shareholder to recapitalize it to the minimum capital required at the time of its licensing. While the shareholder submitted plans to the Bank of Ghana, these plans have not yielded any success.
Download the full details here.
By Emmanuel K. Dogbevi